What impact does environmental design have on safety in our cities was the question addressed in #TheGlobalGrid March Twitter chat. Safety is a core element of a quality urban life. A safe city ensures that all its city residents have full access to public spaces, amenities, and services and fosters their sense of belonging and ownership. As a nod to the March annual celebration of International Women's Day, we explored the effectiveness of gender-based design approaches as a means to achieve safety for all.
To answer and debate our five Twitter chat questions, we invited four panelists who brought great insight and diversity of opinions and backgrounds to the conversation:
- Minakshi Das, in-house counsel and coordinator of the Global Leadership Series at World Is One News, based in India.
- Kristen Jeffers, founder, and editor-in-chief of The Black Urbanist blog, newsletter, and podcast;
- Katrina Johnston-Zimmerman, an urban anthropologist, founder of THINK.urban and co-founder of the Women Led Cities initiative;
- Mitchell Reardon, an urbanist at Metropolitan Collective. He also co-leads the TH!NK R&D group at IBI Group, experiments lead at Happy City, and sits on the Vancouver Public Space Network board.
Keep reading for a summary of the main takeaways from our March Twitter chat.
- Quantitative indicators are only one layer of the tools to assess urban safety
Quantitative indicators, such as crime rate and health, are not immune to bias. Relying solely on them to measure safety can reflect a skewed image of reality. People’s perception and other qualitative indicators such as walkability, public transit ridership, how busy public spaces are and who is walking, biking, playing and occupying them are as, if not more critical to completing the narrative. The availability and density of technological solutions can also often mask cultural structures which exclude or threaten the safety of a specific group, namely women, from public spaces.
Yes and it's something we've seen in the U.S. Numbers only go so far, but they can also provide the right frame to dig deeper in the narratives and other qualitative measures #theglobalgrid
— Kristen Jeffers, MPA (@blackurbanist) March 21, 2018
- To be effective, design should be coupled with structural transformations
Design plays an important role in enhancing a city’s functionality and livability. However, design and data-based solutions to improve safety should be accompanied by clear visions and human-centered structural solutions in the areas of urbanism and urbanism education. The introduction of a gender perspective to planning in Sweden had a great impact on urban design by bringing change to the methodologies used to analyze and survey the use of public space.
Within the city-building fields, a gender perspective in higher ed courses plays an important, & underrated role. Every course during my master’s program at Stockholm University and KTH included a gender component. The first course was a major eye-opener for me. #theglobalgrid
— Mitchell Reardon (@MitchellReardon) March 21, 2018
- Diversity in the design and planning profession is critical to achieving a safe city for all
The success of a gender approach in planning and designing for safety in cities depends on including women in the different processes leading to planning and designing public spaces, whether as users or planners and designers.
A4. Gender equity is crucial 2achieve social justice goal. Men&Women both have different needs. The idea is 2b fair 2 both the sexes by understanding the needs and requirement of men and women. It is a systematic way2 safe city planning and more inclusive #TheGlobalGrid
— Minakshi Das (@minakshi88das) March 21, 2018
Women, as well as all other marginalized groups, should be represented and included in the different professional bodies dealing with the design and governance of cities, in addition to community leadership, to ensure that the resulting physical spaces are indeed adapted and safe for everyone. Single perspectives and narratives are detrimental to achieving quality and safety in public spaces.
Adding more diverse voices to the process - top-down and bottom-up - can only create a richer outcome. A woman's experience is inherently different due to her position in society (though of course, not exclusively so) so her voice is quite simply necessary. #TheGlobalGrid
— Katrina Johnston-Zimmerman (@think_katrina) March 21, 2018
- Cultural and social values are as important to maintain the cohesion of our cities as physical spaces
Safety might be a precondition for cohesion, but a safe community isn’t always cohesive. Cities are complex ecosystems. Each city is unique. Its dynamics and patterns of life are defined in great part by the interaction and “friction” between its people. Further research and study into human behavior and social constructions are therefore necessary to increase our understanding of the different economic factors, power structures and urban forms at play in a city.
A5: The fact is our cities are weird - we have only been urbanized for a comparatively short amount of time so almost everything we’re doing is new. We need continued research especially w/ #smartcities and we need new perspectives on our urban habitats. #TheGlobalGrid 3/3
— Katrina Johnston-Zimmerman (@think_katrina) March 21, 2018
Do you feel safe in your city? What does, or does not, make you feel safe? How does the physical space and design influence your perception of safety? Share your experience and insights with us in the comments section below.
For the full conversation, check our Twitter moment and don’t miss next month’s #TheGlobalGrid Twitter chat on Wednesday, April 18th at 12:00 p.m. PT. We’ll be discussing how green roofs can support city sustainability goals with our co-host Greenroofs and a group of experts. Do you have ideas for topics that you would like to discuss with us in future chats? Let us know. We look forward to your participation!
